Philadelphia Phillies: Grading Ruben Amaro Jr.’s Last 25 Roster Additions

When a ship starts to sink, the first thing that everyone on board starts to do is find the holes. It’s common sense. If you can find the holes, plug them and bail some of the water over the sides, then you can keep the ship afloat. You can even sail back home if you do a good enough job.

Well, if the Philadelphia Phillies were the ship in this analogy, they’d be sinking fast. The time has come where everyone knows that the ship is sinking and now, it’s up to the front office to find the right plugs.

But long after the ship is either sunken or fixed, the time will come when the people on board will look back and want answers. Why did the ship sink? Why was the ship even in that predicament? Could it have been prevented? Why wasn’t it?

It’s a pretty common question for the Phillies this season: “Why?”

This isn’t a team that was built, despite all of its injuries, to play in last place. It is the job of the general manager, Ruben Amaro Jr., to ensure that his team has the best shot at the postseason.

So naturally, when the ship starts to sink, Amaro is the guy that gets the blame.

This slideshow is going to analyze the last 25 roster additions that Amaro made to the MLB roster in an effort to improve the product in some way, shape or form. The roster additions extend over the last two seasons and include a number of various transactions.

That includes free-agent signings, trades, minor league call-ups (not September call-ups), etc.

Begin Slideshow

MLB Trade Speculation: Should Phillies Deal Cliff Lee, Sign Hamels Long Term?

With the Philadelphia Phillies looking up at the rest of the National League East in the standings, they may make the decision to be sellers at the trade deadline this year. If this is the route they choose to take, then the questions become which players would be willing to move.

One of the players the Phillies may consider dealing this winter is Cole Hamels. He is going to become a free agent after the year, and one agent believes Hamels will be able to get a deal with a higher annual value than CC Sabathia’s contract if he hits the open market (via Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports).

Buster Olney of ESPN has noted that there are a number of pros and cons to both trading Hamels and to keeping him. Trading away a player of Hamels’ caliber would bring back a few elite prospects, but the Phillies would lose almost any chance they had to re-sign him.

There is a way the Phillies could free up some money that they could use to sign Hamels this winter. Joel Sherman of the New York Post has suggested the Phillies could trade Cliff Lee and then choose to build around Hamels.

Lee has $75 million left on his contract for the next three seasons as well as a $27.5 million option with a $12.5 million buyout for the 2016 season. If Lee is dealt, that money could be shifted towards a new contract for Hamels.

There are other benefits of trading Lee. Dealing Lee would allow the Philadelphia Phillies to restock their farm system. The team has a farm system that ranks near the bottom of the MLB, and the prospects acquired in any deal involving Lee would be the type of players who could make an impact in the major leagues sooner rather than later.

A potential issue arises if the Phillies try to trade Lee. He has a no-trade clause that includes nine teams (via NY Post). This could really limit the teams the Phillies can try to negotiate with, since some big-market clubs that can afford Lee may actually be on the list.

Philadelphia is currently in a situation where they need to get younger. Their average age is 31.5 years old, and they need to focus on keeping their younger players and bringing in new talent.

Trading Lee will allow the Phillies to do this, because they can go all out to offer Hamels the money that he wants. Hamels will be in a position to serve an ace on the Phillies staff for years to come, and he will be a piece to build around.

There is also a chance the Phillies trade Lee and then are unable to sign Hamels. The Los Angeles Dodgers could have Hamels at the top of their list this offseason and may be willing spend whatever it takes to sign him (via Twitter).

Philadelphia should try to sign Hamels to an extension if they deal Lee, because there is a legitimate chance they will lose Hamels if he hits the market. The Phillies would be in a very rough spot if they lost both Lee and Hamels.

Championship teams are ones that are not afraid to take risks. Without risks there are no rewards. If the Phillies want to set themselves up for the future, they should deal Lee and then put all their effort into bringing Hamels back.

Read more Philadelphia Phillies news on BleacherReport.com

Philadelphia Phillies: Cole Hamels Steals Show at Shane Victorino Charity Event

Shane Victorino held another fashion show for a great cause, but it was pitcher Cole Hamels who stole the show. 

Dan Gross of The Philadelphia Daily News reports on Victorino holding his third annual fashion show to benefit the Shane Victorino Foundation. 

The Union League was filled with stars helping the foundation whose mission statement is,”dedicated to promoting opportunities for underserved youth. The Foundation engages in projects which provide children in need with educational, recreational and wellness programs.”

This year, current Phillies and their families were joined by the likes of Bernard Hopkins and Joe Piscopo. 

The night belonged to Hamels who wore this ensemble which is now the talk of the fashion world. Okay, it’s merely the talk of people who consider capris and highly-cuffed pants to be rather silly. 

Hamels is making a habit of creating the fashion stir. Last year when he, as The Big Lead put it, embraced his inner Ace Ventura. 

I think he really sets the bar high with his bright-red high water pants. Those things could be more red, but not by much. 

From a sports land filled with emerging hipsters, I would expect this wardrobe to feature on a podium shortly. 

Of course, the event was without Chase Utley who continues to rehab with what I like to describe as crappy knee syndrome. 

His wonderful wife, Jennifer, was escorted by the Phillie Phanatic down the catwalk. 

That video should serve to remind other, younger Phanatics that you too can grow up to be a dapper superstar. 

Another night of fun and frivolity was had, and Hamels once again hit it out of the park. 

Follow me on Twitter for one hell of a good time. 

Follow @gabezal

Read more Philadelphia Phillies news on BleacherReport.com

Philadelphia Phillies Retired Numbers: Who’s Next?

I suppose I wasn’t totally lost when I ran my poll (forever ago) on what team to cover next in my Retired Number Series. I have a list of possible teams sitting on my notes, and the Phillies have been towards the top of the list for a while now. So, when they tied at the top of the poll for which team to write about next, I gave this de facto tie breaker to them.

I don’t really have any specific feelings for the Phillies one way or the other, I guess. I do think that they are similar to the Mariners, though, in that they have many intriguing candidates on the horizon.

Begin Slideshow

Cole Hamels: Phillies Need to Learn from Brewers’ Mistake Not Trading Fielder

Cole Hamels should be traded, the sooner the better. 

It is the only way for the Phillies to keep their present backslide from turning into an outright collapse.  Coming off the heels of five terrific seasons, this team and this season have the feel of a once really great party that is now degenerating into chaos.

From 2007-2011, Phillies fans loved the five straight division titles.  They loved the 102 wins last season.  Heady days.  For the last five years, it was a bottle service blowout where miraculously the longer the party went on, the hotter everyone seemed to get. 

Every time the action started to flag, someone else better than the previous player walked through the door. 

“Brett Myers had to leave.  Oh, but look, it’s Brad Lidge.”  “Jamie Moyer said he was tired, he went home.  But Roy Halladay just showed up and brought Cliff Lee with him!”  “Chase Utley says his knee is bothering him and he needs to go crash in the back bedroom.  Thankfully, Hunter Pence’s date went home with a stomach virus so he came after all!” 

Time after glorious time, whenever it looked like the show might finally be over, Ruben Amaro Jr. came through with another signing, another trade, another move to keep the music playing.

Unfortunately, it is becoming horribly apparent that in propping the “we can win a title” window open for as long as possible, the Phillies exposed themselves to that phenomenon most party-goers can relate to.

For the Phillies, now, that same rollicking fiesta that carried them for five years has gone to a dark place.  It is 2:55 a.m.  The beautiful people who formed the epicenter of the good times have started falling asleep in corners or leaving altogether. 

Halladay is 4-5 with an ERA (3.98) that has not been this high since 2007.  Right now, of course, he is not pitching at all.  Lee is 0-3 and doesn’t even win when he shuts the Giants out for ten innings or is staked to three-run leads. 

And Utley and Ryan Howard sneaked out the back door; people are saying they are coming back, but you can only believe that if/when you see it. 

The Phillies are six games under .500.  Guests are leaving in droves: See the empty seats at Citizens’ Bank Park, which figure to be pronounced this week home to the Colorado Rockies.

Lee will win a game this season.  Halladay will pitch again this season.  Utley and Howard will play again this season.  Unfortunately, by the time they all come back to the party, the lights will already have been turned off.  It is over. 

It is not that they are nine games back in the division—they have to pass four teams to get back to the top from last place.  It is not that they are five games back in the wild card standings—they have to pass seven teams to get there.

There is no way to save 2012.  The time has come to work on saving 2013 and beyond.  Ironically, that process starts for the Phillies with trading this season’s most valuable player.  Cole Hamels must go.

He is both an elite talent and a proven playoff performer.  As the playoff contenders sort themselves out, teams will fight over Hamels.  They will do so as much to keep him away from other contending teams as they will to secure his services for themselves. 

The Phillies can jump-start the process of re-stocking their depleted farm system by igniting a bidding war for a World Series MVP.

This will be a bitter pill for the Phillies, as Hamels is home-grown.  Their fans will not like it any better. 

Trading Hamels will be the flying white flag the fanbase has not seen in almost a decade.  And he will be missed.  Here is the thing, though: Phillies fans can begin missing Hamels now or in November, when Hamels signs for eight years and $150M with the Dodgers, or the Yankees, or the Rangers.

If the Phillies need proof that this is the right move, they need only look directly behind them in the wild card standings.  There sit the Milwaukee Brewers, behind the Phillies only in winning percentage. 

The Brewers had the chance to sell Prince Fielder to the highest bidder at last season’s trade deadline.  They kept him, ultimately getting nothing of real value for Fielder when he signed with the Detroit Tigers in the past offseason.

The Brewers’ choice was defensible in that, with Fielder, the 2011 Brewers were an excellent team.  They won 96 games, they won their division, they won a playoff series.  With Fielder leaving, the Brewers likely knew that their 2011 iteration was their last best chance to win.  So they went for it. 

Conversely, the 2012 Phillies aren’t great…heck, they are not even good.

A year later, the Brewers are in a downward spiral and looking like sellers (Zack Greinke?) at the deadline themselves.

While they are at it, the Phillies could also consider parting with Shane Victorino and 2011 deadline darling Pence.  Whatever it takes to get younger, cheaper and eventually more competitive.

Nobody likes working through the housecleaning after the party ends.  Without it, though, stuff will really start to stink.

Read more Philadelphia Phillies news on BleacherReport.com

Each Philadelphia Phillies Player’s Season Explained in 140 Characters or Less

The last place Philadelphia Phillies.

For a team with one of baseball’s largest payrolls, it doesn’t seem like much of a possibility, but somehow, it’s something that the Phillies have managed to accomplish.

Just a year after assembling the “four aces,” the Phillies are stuck in the National League East’s cellar. They went from having two Roys in the rotation to having none, though Roy Halladay will return, but who’s to say that the division crown isn’t out of reach by that point?

The Phillies’ disabled list has looked more like their 25-man roster than their 25-man roster this season. Halladay, Ryan Howard, Jose Contreras, Michael Martinez, Chase Utley, Justin De Fratus, Cliff Lee, Michael Stutes, Jim Thome, David Herndon, Laynce Nix, Vance Worley and Freddy Galvis have all hit the DL this season.

In more ways than one, it sure seems like a lost cause. The rhetoric has always been that if the Phillies could keep in the race with their big names on the DL, they would be able to jump back into the lead at some point once they returned.

But that possibility seems like it slips further and further away with each passing day. It may be time to admit that the Phillies, as they are currently constructed, just can’t make a run this year. Sure, they were dealt a bad hand, but that’s not an excuse.

Maybe it’s time to retool.

Until then, here’s a clever way of showing you what went wrong (or right, in that rare moment) for each of the Phillies’ players this season—in just 140 characters.

Begin Slideshow

MLB Trade Deadline: Cole Hamels and 4 Others Who Could Bolster a Rotation

As the days dwindle to the MLB trade deadline, teams will be searching left and right for starting pitching. Luckily for them, some top flight pitchers, including Cole Hamels, are on deck. 

Although the price tag will be high for a World Series champion like Hamels, there are several other quality starters who could be on the move this summer. 

With teams always in need of pitching help, let’s take a look at five starters who could fortify a team’s rotation for the second half of the season. 

Begin Slideshow

Philadelphia Phillies: Some Hope in Looking Back at June 17 Standings

The hope for the 2012 season was to stay afloat until stars Ryan Howard and Chase Utley return from the disabled list.  Ace starter Roy Halladay was added to that list when he went down three weeks ago.  The Phillies were doing a pretty good job of hanging around and after 53 games were a season-high three games above .500 and just 2.5 games out of first.

Then, simultaneously, the Phillies went ice cold while the Nationals took off.  The Phils have gone 3-11 in their last 14 games, dropping to 31-36 and nine game back of first.  It hasn’t just been their bats this time either.  Since Roy Halladay was placed on the DL, the Phils have gone 6-12 and have averaged 5.3 runs allowed per game. Before Doc went on the DL, they were allowing 3.9 per game.  Here is some more ugliness since Halladay went to the shelf:

Cliff Lee: four starts, 0-14.72 ERA, 1.43 WHIP

Cole Hamels: four starts, 2-2  6.07 ERA, 1.27 WHIP

Joe Blanton:  four starts, 2-2  5.74 ERA, 1.35 WHIP

Kyle Kendrick: three starts, 1-2  7.80 ERA, 1.80 WHIP

Vance Worley:  three starts, 0-1  2.12 ERA, 1.18 WHIP

 

Only Worley has been effective during this stretch.  It’s also been 19 games since the Phillies won a game where they scored fewer than six runs.  That’s asking a lot out of an offense that is forced to roll the Hector Luna’s and Mike Fontenot’s of the world out there on a consistent basis.

So the question has been asked many times recently: are the Phillies doomed?

Taking a look at the June 17th standings the previous four years, the answer is no.  Teams that were in first place or would have been the league’s wild card representative if the season ended on June 17 have made the playoffs 68.8 percent of the time.  Naturally that indicates that 31.2 percent of the time a team that is not in the field on June 17 has made the playoffs.

This time last season, the Red Sox, Indians and Giants were all in first place and failed to make the playoffs.  The Braves would have been the wild card team on June 17 and collapsed as well, so the percentage was 50 percent last year. 

Even more drastic, the 2005 Houston Astros went on to win the National League pennant.  Want to know what their record was on June 17, 2005?  How about 27-38. 

Two seasons earlier, the Florida Marlins won the World Series.  Their record on June 17, 2003 was 34-38.  Last year’s World Champs were 38-33 on this date and the AL pennant winners, the Texas Rangers, were 37-34.

The Phillies still have hope, but a number of things need to turn around to go on a run like the ’05 Astros, the ’03 Marlins, the ’07 Rockies or the ’10 Phillies who were 34-30 and in third place.

• Utley and Howard must come back and produce near the all-star level we are accustomed to seeing from them.
• Halladay must return to his Cy Young ways.
• Lee needs to pitch like a $21-million pitcher.
• Jimmy Rollins and Shane Victorino need to return to their catalyst ways setting the table for the big boppers to drive in.
• Someone, anyone needs to step up in the bullpen besides Jonathan Papelbon.
• Charlie Manuel needs to pitch Papelbon more in tight games.  Eight walk-off losses in which Papelbon didn’t even pitch, is beyond unacceptable.

Yes, things aren’t looking good for the ’12 Philadelphia Phillies but it’s far from over.  A number of teams have “righted the ship” and made their way to the postseason.  It’s a tall order this season, but it can be done.

Read more Philadelphia Phillies news on BleacherReport.com

Carlos Ruiz Possibly Headed to the Disabled List; Implications for Phillies

Aside from the free-swinging Hunter Pence, the only other constant within the Philadelphia Phillies‘ positional depth chart has been the catcher we all know as Chooch. Unfortunately, Carlos Ruiz may have to spend some time on the DL.

Ruiz strained his left oblique during Friday night’s ball game versus the Toronto Blue Jays. Phillies skipper Charlie Manuel has declared that Ruiz will have to rest a few games. On the other hand, we will know the extent of the oblique strain today as the Phillies re-evaluate their slugging backstop. Following Saturday’s re-evaluation will be a determination as to whether or not the organization will place Ruiz on the DL.

Meanwhile, the Phillies have already re-called catcher Erik Kratz from Triple-A Lehigh Valley and the full-time job has already been given to Brian Schneider while Ruiz is ailing.

Of course, a Ruiz injury will just follow suit to everything else that has happened to the Phillies since last October. Injuries to Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Roy Halladay, Jose Contreras, Freddy Galvis and so on have given the Phillies’ roster more holes than a slice of Swiss cheese.

Sprinkle in an oblique strain for Ruiz and it is time for the Phillies to come out and say what everyone is thinking—it’s time to sell.

Many folks have called this season a lost season. In a previous article, I discussed how the Phillies could save this season by preparing the roster for a return to a high level of competitiveness for 2013.

The loss of Ruiz, who is hitting .362 with eight home runs and 35 RBI, would be decimating.

What is more important is that Ruiz provided stability against left-handed pitchers, hitting .409 on the year with only five strike outs.

I don’t even have to touch on the magic that Ruiz performs behind home plate, either. He is one of the top defensive backstops in all of baseball.

While nothing has been confirmed yet, a loss of Ruiz would definitively place the Phillies in a position where they must begin shopping the like’s of Shane Victorino, Jim Thome, Joe Blanton, and (gulp) Cole Hamels.

Baseball is a business and the business environment of 2012 has been harsh for the Philadelphia Phillies. Now is the time to make the tough decisions and put the Phillies in a better place for 2013.

Read more Philadelphia Phillies news on BleacherReport.com

Philadelphia Phillies 2012 Season Can Be Repaired, but at What Cost?

That sound you hear isn’t the toilet flushing. Rather, it is the panic that has emancipated itself from the high hopes that were brought forth when the Philadelphia Phillies first took to the diamond in 2012.

Most people saw through the gilded exterior of the 2012 Phillies 40-man roster to a problem that was looming ahead. The problem is three-fold, and here, halfway through June, it has finally reared its ugly head.

The problem isn’t that the Phillies are nine games behind the Washington Nationals in the N.L. East. The problem lies in the discarded waste laid forth by general manager Ruben Amaro Jr. in his quest to build a franchise that would be the king of the mountaintop, albeit a temporary mountaintop.

Die-hard fans and insiders, (yes, the die-hard phanatical fans in Philadelphia come first), both knew something was seriously wrong with the atmosphere in Philly. Ironically enough, while both contingents acknowledged something was wrong, no one knew what specifically was wrong.

Tired discussions of how a healthy Chase Utley and Ryan Howard could help this ballclub aside, the problem lies in GM Amaro Jr.’s management of this team.

First, Amaro Jr. was duped by Utley’s own prognosis concerning the lower half of his frame.

Second, Howard’s timetable to return has been unclear, and Amaro Jr. has not been forthright when it comes to public relations.

Third, no one in their right mind expected the Phillie rotation to pitch as splendidly as it did in 2011.

The first two topics speak for themselves.

On the third topic, Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee and Cole Hamels are monsters. Yet, all of the reports out of Clearwater during the spring were focused on Halladay’s diminished velocity, Lee’s elbow concerns and Hamels’ contract situation.

Thus far, the latter two issues have been more accurate than any reporting on Hamels’ ability to function with his long-term status in Philadelphia in doubt.

As good as Vance Worley was as a rookie, his BABIP and other metrics suggest that he pitched over his head.

Also, while Joe Blanton has looked good periodically in 2012, nobody expected Blanton to fully earn the $8.5 million he is making this year.

Meanwhile, Amaro Jr.’s idea for fortifying the house that manager Charlie Manuel built was to give the aging Jimmy Rollins a lucrative deal that will likely backfire (if it hasn’t already).

Furthermore, Amaro overpaid for a closer in Jonathan Papelbon, and bypassed power hitters like Josh Willingham, Michael Cuddyer and Jason Kubel for light-hitting Ty Wigginton, Juan Pierre and Jim Thome.

While I recognize that Thome has been on a tear during interleague play, he offers nothing as a full-time player at 1B once interleague is over. Also, his pinch-hitting statistics are worse than former Phillie Ross Gload’s.

Needless to say, Amaro Jr. swung and missed big time with this roster.

Instead of locking up Cole Hamels with a long-term deal, he decided to sure up Jimmy Rollins at shortstop—a contract that Amaro Jr. will want to quickly forget come next season.

On the bright side, Placido Polanco, Shane Victorino, Juan Pierre, Jim Thome and Joe Blanton will likely be gone next year.

On the downside, so will Cole Hamels.

With that in mind, the Phillies can do three things to drastically help curb the downslide they are currently mired in.

First, trade Cole Hamels.

I know, it seems crazy. Even with Roy Halladay on the disabled list, the Phillies should trade Hamels to the highest bidder and receive the appropriate high-level prospects in return.

Then, in the offseason, the Phillies can turn around and re-sign Hamels (I know, nearly a pipe dream, but it can be done). By doing this, Amaro Jr. would be able to maximize his return for Hamels, and bring Hamels back to the red pinstripes in 2013.

Second, Amaro Jr. must move Jim Thome while he is hot. The Cleveland Indians would be the ideal situation, since their current DH, Johnny Damon, is swinging and missing at beach balls. The return on Thome may not be great, but it could be satisfactory.

Third, trade Shane Victorino and give Domonic Brown one more shot in the Show.

Victorino is not going to be back in Philly next season due to the contract he will likely get somewhere else, so why not move him for some long-term depth or a veteran reliever?

Amaro Jr. can also give former five-tool prospect Dom Brown one last chance to prove himself. It’s not like Brown isn’t tearing the cover off of the ball at Lehigh Valley.

While my three proposals are not likely to yield a playoff appearance for the Phillies in 2012, they are a realistic approach to saving the 2012 season while also keeping an eye on a rebound year in 2013.

Read more Philadelphia Phillies news on BleacherReport.com

« Previous Page — Next Page »